After my huge disappointment from my visit to Family History Library, I have struggled to get back in to my research. It seems like everything leads to dead ends. Every time I decide to go back and search another branch of the tree, I end up going back to my great grandmother trying to find some hint that will connect her to the many, many Ontario Canniff’s .
I am fairly certain that the Thomas Canniff of Michigan that immigrated from Hastings, Ontario is either not the same as the Jonas Canniff in the 1881 and 1871 census, or if it is, he is likely not related to my great grandmother. He list Jonas Canniff and Jane Lucas as his parents in his marriage license. I had thought that Phoebe Canniff may have been another sister. and was buoyed when I found her with her parents Jonas Canniff and Jane Lucas. But alas, her parents lived much past 1868, thus eliminating them as parents of my Lydia Jane.
So, now back to DNA. I was in high hopes that my 87 year old aunt would agree to testing, but when I visited her with test in hand she declined, feeling it was “creepy.” But, all hope is not dead. I was checking my nephew’s matches in ancestry the other day, and found one that not only has Canniff in his surname list, but he is a Canniff! He is a 5th to 8th cousin to my nephew, even though he does not match me. Ancestry has a new feature called “Shared Matches.” When I clicked on this new Canniff there were two more DNA matches. Now we have a total of four, (6 with my nephew and I) certified CANNIFF matches! All of us have Abraham T. Canniff b. 1770 d. 1843, m. Mariejte Tietsoort. Three have the next generation Jonas Weeks Canniff 1797 and the others have Isaac Canniff 1806. It is ever so slowly chipping away.
I tried to join the Quinte Branch of the Ontario Genealogical Society, but will wait until November when I can get a full year. In the meantime I found the main branch Facebook page, and some very nice and helpful people. They lead me to the Directory of Hastings County 1860. This is two years before my great grandmother was born, so hoping to find her father here. So far I have found a Jonas Canniff, Phillip Flagler Canniff, James Canniff and a few others. Jonas owned a “flouring mill”, and was a trustee of the Weslyan Methodist Church. Does this give me any hints? Not really. But it was fun to find. It also listed the by laws of the county. The early homesteaders were given 100 of which they had to build a house and plant crops in at least 20 acres of the land within the first year. Building the house done by the neighbors all pitching in and building a log house that was complete in 4-5 days. They also had regulations for all the men and young boys, should a fire break out. Everything from who would haul water to ringing the bell to warn and gather people together. I felt like even though I didn’t learn any specifics as to who is the father of my great grandmother, it was fun to put myself in their lives for a few minutes.
I have ordered a book on the history of Belleville, Ontario. It should be here in a couple days. Can’t wait to start weeding through that one!